
LAST WEEK RECAP
Michigan survived a scare from Rutgers for the second season in a row. This time the Scarlet Knights were the team coming back from a 17-point deficit, but the Wolverines made the stops they needed to hold on 20-13.
NEXT UP: @ Wisconsin: 11th, 16.9
PREGAME SP+: U-M by 1.0, Michigan Win Probability 52%
Only 3 spots separate Michigan and Wisconsin in the SP+ rankings, despite the Wolverines’ (4-0) and Badgers’ (1-2) vastly different records. Wisconsin’s two losses have come to SP+ #5 Penn State and #22 Notre Dame.
Michigan Offense (17th) vs. Wisconsin Defense (4th)
One primary reason I ground my expectations in analytics involves avoiding recency bias. Even though Michigan’s offense had been a juggernaut for 6 out of 8 quarters this season, the last 2 quarters against Rutgers are fresh in the minds of all Michigan fans. Although the rushing attack sputtered, and the passing game could not find their rhythm last Saturday, the Wolverines still sit at #17 in SP+ offense rankings. That’s 1 spot in front of Penn State, and 22 spots ahead of Notre Dame.
On the flip side Wisconsin has an elite defensive unit, especially against the run. I don’t expect to see the Badgers surrender a large number of scoring chances. That means we’ll keep an eye on IsoPPP to measure how explosive Michigan can be when they do find successful plays.
Points per Scoring Opportunity also shines as a critical metric for this game . When the offense penetrates the Wisconsin 40-yard line, they will need to score touchdowns rather than settling for field goal attempts.
Michigan Defense (8th) vs. Wisconsin Offense (50th)
We can reasonably say that Mike MacDonald’s defensive unit saved Michigan’s victory over Rutgers. When SP+ ranked the Wolverines’ defense #10 in the preseason, I mentioned that I thought that was inflated. Through 4 weeks, Michigan has not only validated that initial ranking, but continued to climb as preseason expectations are removed from the SP+ model.
In this week’s matchup with the Badgers, the Michigan defense represents the largest unit-versus-unit advantage for the Wolverines. If the defense can create havoc and negative plays early in this game, they may be able to help subdue the crowd’s energy. The Badgers’ fan base is starving for some positivity during their rocky start to the 2021 season. Aidan Hutchinson, Dax Hill, and Josh Ross need to implant doubt & negative vibes into the Camp Randall crowd as early as possible.
PREDICTION: The range of possible outcomes for this game extends to both ends of the spectrum. It could be a nail-biter for the duration. However, the conditions feel right for either team to play poorly and get boat-raced off the field.
The early season narrative for the Badgers starts with QB Graham Mertz struggling and turning the ball over. Michigan continues to protect the ball very well to this point of the season. If the turnover margin continues on that trend, then we could be celebrating a huge road victory from Madison.
I expect both teams to play conservatively to limit the big momentum swings. I can’t yet bring myself to predict a fast start and a complete 60-minute performance from Michigan on the road. I still need to see a sharp game plan from each coordinator, and the leaders on the field consistently execute at a high level.
Michigan 17 Wisconsin 20 (PRESEASON Michigan 24 Wisconsin 30)
MICHIGAN RESUME UPDATE (9/26/21), 4-0
- SP+ Overall: 8th (↓2), 20.4
- SP+ Offense: 17th (↓4), 35.8
- SP+ Defense: 8th (same), 15.8
- SP+ Special Teams: 9th (↓7), 0.3
AP Poll: 14th (↑5), 677
Coaches’ Poll: 14th (↑5), 674
CFP Rank: N/A
