THE GAME – Michigan vs Ohio State Football – Looking Back – 1956

Looking Back is a Special Feature by Jeff Cummins Highlighting Key Rivalry Games

The first installment of this year’s series looking back at the football rivalry between Michigan and Ohio State takes us back to 1956. The national economy was roaring, having reached $400 billion. Low unemployment combined with strong income disbursement led many young people to start families, and purchase homes and automobiles.

On the gridiron, Michigan had fallen to Ohio State the two previous seasons, sparking a determination in coach Bennie Oosterbaan and his players to reverse this disturbing trend. The 1956 Wolverines were led by tight end Ron Kramer, a consensus All-America selection who was later named to the College Football Hall of Fame. Jim Van Pelt played quarterback, and most of the running was done by senior halfback Terry Barr. As the two rivals took the field, each team wore its home uniform, an interesting custom maintained to this day by USC and UCLA.

Operating from the T-formation, the Wolverines wasted little time establishing their attack. Their backs pierced the Ohio State defensive line for small but certain gains, forcing the Buckeyes to concentrate on stopping the run. Van Pelt exploited this, connecting with Barr on a 21-yard swing pass to give Michigan a 7-0 lead. Michigan recovered an Ohio State fumble on the ensuing kickoff, but the Buckeye defense immediately stifled any threat. Undeterred, the Wolverines recovered another fumble on Ohio State’s next possession, and this time Michigan cashed in. Unable to find an open receiver, Barr sprinted for a 4-yard touchdown on an option play to give Michigan a 13-0 lead.

From that point, the Michigan defense took control of the game. The Wolverines tacked on another touchdown in the fourth quarter, but the Michigan defense was the real star. The Wolverines intercepted two passes, while allowing Ohio State to complete just one pass, essentially shutting down the Buckeye passing attack. Michigan won, 19-0, and finished the season with a record of seven wins and two losses. There was no bowl game, but a victory over the Buckeyes is always worth celebrating.

Thanks to YouTube poster College Football Historian for the film of this game. As always, we own nothing and this blog is published strictly for the enjoyment of readers.

Nothing But ‘Net – Week #04 – 11/20/2023 – Back To Earth

The University of Michigan men’s basketball team played two games this past week, and they won one and lost the other.  On Monday (11/13/2023), they beat St. John’s 89-73 in Madison Square Garden in New York City (a Gavitt Tipoff Game), then on Friday (11/17/2023), they lost to Long Beach State 94-86 in Crisler Arena.  The win and the loss leave Michigan with a record of 3-1.

What Happened?

After playing very well in their first three games, fans were starting to raise their expectations about this season’s team.  Long Beach State?  Another blowout win!  Wrong.  Back to Earth.  While this team might still exceed initial expectations, they are not going to blowout every opponent on the way to an undefeated season and a National Championship.

First, the delightful St. John’s game.  This was Michigan’s toughest test to date in the young season, and they passed it with flying colors.  It was a fun game to watch on TV, since the announcers were so excited about the Return Of Rick Pitino.  Michigan ran SJU out of the gym.  The game started out as a see-saw battle, with the lead going back and forth.  With 7:14 to go in the 1st half, it was all tied up, 28-28.  SJU went ahead, 31-29, at the 6:28 mark, and that was the last time they led.  Michigan ended the half with a 19-7 run, to lead 48-38 at halftime.  The 2nd half was all Michigan, as they pushed the lead up as high as 26 points, before the Scout Team let SJU sneak back to within 16 points at the end.

Speaking of 16 points, that was the high water mark for Michigan in the ill-fated LBSU game.  Michigan started strong, and built up a 16 point lead (23-7) with 13:16 to go in the 1st half.  It looked like LBSU was going to fold and UM was going to get another blowout win, but the Beach didn’t give up.  Michigan still led by 12 points (32-20) at the 8:56 mark, and 10 points (34-24) with 7:38 to go.  That’s when UM stopped playing defense, and LBSU went on a 24-16 run to end the half.  That cut Michigan’s lead to 2 points (50-48) at halftime.  The 2nd half was a disaster.  The lead went back and forth, with LBSU ahead for most of the half.  Still, UM kept battling, and they actually got a small lead (80-76) with 4:28 left in the game.  LBSU outscored them 18-6 down the stretch, to win by 8.  It was frustrating.

Stats

The game stats for the SJU game were pretty good.  Michigan shot well overall (32-for-62 = 51.6%), they shot 3-pointers well (11-for-26 = 42.3%), and they shot free throws decently (14-for-23 = 60.9%).  They lost the rebounding battle (39-47) and the turnover battle (13-11).  They won this game with good shooting and defense.  The biggest negative was that SJU grabbed 27 offensive rebounds, for 33 second-chance points.

The game stats for the LBSU game were mediocre.  Michigan shot decently overall (31-for-66 = 47.0%), they shot 3-pointers poorly (9-for-28 = 32.1%), and they shot free throws decently (15-for-25 = 60.0%).  They won the rebounding battle (38-30), but lost the turnover battle (16-12).  They lost this game with poor 3-point shooting and too many turnovers.

Who Started?

The starters for both games were Nimari Burnett, Dug McDaniel, Olivier Nkamhoua, Tarris Reed, Jr., and Terrance Williams II.

Who Looked Good?

McDaniel was the star this week, with 26 (a new career high) and 20 points.  He was the leading scorer in the SJU game, and 2nd leading scorer vs. LBSU.  He also had 7 and 6 assists.  Unfortunately, he had 6 turnovers vs. LBSU, several of them at key moments in the closing minutes of the game.

Nkamhoua had a decent game vs. SJU (9 points) and was the leading scorer vs. LBSU (22 points).  He also had 7 and 11 rebounds, giving him another double-double vs. LBSU.

Williams was the only other player to hit double figures in both games, with 12 and 10 points.  He wasn’t very efficient: 5-for-12 overall (2-for-6 from deep) vs. SJU, and 2-for-8 overall (2-for-7 from deep) vs. LBSU.  His poor shooting vs. LBSU really cost Michigan in that game.

Burnett had a career game vs. SJU (21 points) and a mediocre game vs. LBSU (5 points).  He scored all 21 of his points in the 1st half of the SJU game, shooting 8-for-8 overall, 4-for-4 from deep.  Unfortunately, he shot 0-for-5 overall (0-for-3 from deep) in the 2nd half of the SJU game, and 2-for-9 overall (1-for-7 from deep) vs. LBSU, for a combined 2-for-14 overall (1-for-10 from deep) since that 1st half outburst.  His poor shooting vs. LBSU really cost Michigan in that game.

Reed had a quiet week, with 5 and 8 points.  He was the leading rebounder in the SJU game with 11, and he had 4 more rebounds vs. LBSU.

Will Tschetter had one good game (10 points vs. SJU) and one quiet game (4 points vs. LBSU).

Tray Jackson had one very good game (17 points vs. LBSU) and one quiet game (4 points vs. SJU).

Who Looked Not-So-Good?

George Washington III played in both games (5 and 4 minutes), and failed to score.  He took one shot, in the SJU game.

Who Else Played?

Harrison Hochberg played for 1 minute in the SJU game, and didn’t attempt a shot.

Youssef Khayat played in the SJU game, and scored 2 points.

Jackson Selvala played for 1 minute in the SJU game, and didn’t attempt a shot.

Cooper Smith played for 1 minute in the SJU game, and didn’t attempt a shot.

Who Didn’t Play?

Ian Burns didn’t play in either game.

Jace Howard and Jaelin Llewellyn are injured, and not playing yet.  They are both expected back “later in the season”.

What Does It Mean?

It wasn’t surprising that Michigan went 1-1 last week, but it would have made more sense for them to lose their first road game against a team coached by Rick Pitino and beat Long Beach State in Crisler.  Wrong.  Oh well.  We knew they weren’t going to win them all, but I think most people expected them to beat LBSU.  This just shows that this is a team that hasn’t been playing together for very long, and that they’ve got some work to do.  They could still have a better season than predicted, but they’ve got to avoid those upsets.

What’s Next?

This week, Michigan plays three games, all in the Battle 4 Atlantis tournament in Paradise Island, Bahamas.  On Wednesday (11/22/2023, 5:00 p.m., ESPN2) they play Memphis, on Thursday (11/23/2023, 5:00/7:30 p.m., ESPN/ESPNU) they play (#14) Arkansas/Stanford, then on Friday (11/24/2023, TBA, TBA) they play one of the teams from the other half of the bracket ([#20] North Carolina, Northern Iowa, Texas Tech, or [#21] Villanova).  The full bracket is here.

Memphis is currently 3-0, with a win over Missouri.  They were 26-9 (13-5 in the AAC) last season, with some decent wins.  They won the AAC conference tournament, then lost in the 1st round of the NCAA Tournament to Florida Atlantic.  They don’t have any noteworthy players, and they’ve only got one tall player, a 6’11” redshirt senior.  This game is a toss-up.  If Michigan plays like they did in their first three games, they’ll stand a good chance against Memphis.  If they play like they did in the 2nd half vs. LBSU, not so much.

The way the tournament bracket is set up, it is crucial to win the first game.  That gets you into the winner’s bracket, where the worst you can do is 4th place.  Lose on the first day, and you drop into the loser’s bracket, where 5th place is the best you can do.  When Michigan played in the Battle 4 Atlantis tournament in November 2019, they won a hard-fought game against Iowa State in the 1st round, then upset (#6) North Carolina and (#8) Gonzaga to win it all.  I went to that tournament, and it was a great time.  I hope UM can play that well again.

Check back next week to find out what happened and why.

Go Blue!

Michigan 31 Maryland 24 – Game 11 Recap

GAME 11 PROJECTION vs. RESULTS

Final Score: 31-24, Michigan by 7 over Maryland
SP+ Projection: Michigan by 20.9 (-13.9)
CD Projection: Michigan by 26 (-19)

FIVE FACTORS

GAME 11 RECAP @ Maryland

A common assumption coming into this trap game was that big chunks of Michigan’s play book were likely off limits. JJ McCarthy kept for a short loss on just one surprising read option. Also, I don’t recall a single target for Donovan Edwards in the air. For the 2nd consecutive week, the Wolverines succeeded in winning on the road using predominantly their base run & pass plays. JJ was a bit off target, going 12-23 for 141 yards, 0 TD & 1 INT. Also of note, starting tackle Ladarius Henderson was not available, and back up Myles Hinton also limped off in the second half.

The Michigan defense provided much more firepower against the Terrapins, but also caused concern. Mike Sainristil stepped forward as a clutch play maker once again with two interceptions. Linebacker depth caused fear when senior Mike Barrett stayed down with an upper body injury, although he returned in the second half. Earlier in the game Barrett’s strip-sack led to Derrick Moore’s defensive touchdown.

Kenneth Grant and Mason Graham both created havoc from their tackle positions. However, we saw multiple DBs, including Sainristil & Will Johnson, give up explosive plays on vertical routes. Playing a bend but don’t break defensive game plan allows some run game success and underneath passes. But, the Wolverines also struggled versus double moves. This test will resurface very soon, from much more talented receivers.

The special teams units were the true stars of the 1,000th win for Michigan. Christian Boivin blocked a punt in the 1st quarter, leading to a 2-point safety. Punter Tommy Doman punted 5 times, averaging 47.2 yards per kick (average net 41 yards). His best came last: a golf shot downed at the Maryland 1 yard line. The Wolverines would get another safety on the ensuing defensive series.

Michigan fans understand being anxious during Game #11. The Wolverines tend to simplify their game plan, and also focus on reducing injury risk with the Buckeyes looming. This particular example weighed extra heavy given the ongoing NCAA investigation and Jim Harbaugh’s 3-game suspension. However, the Wolverines are 11-0 and still have every goal to compete for when Ohio State comes to Ann Arbor in just over six days. Onward!

Michigan Wolverine Football Podcast — Play Angry – Game 11 Maryland Preview

Support the Podcast, Get Gear

Phil @pcallihan and Clint @Clint_Derringer preview the game vs Maryland – SP+ analysis, commentary, and prediction. With Interim Coach Sherrone Moore and Coach Jim Harbaugh.

Subscribe:
Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Google Podcasts | Spotify | Pandora | Stitcher | Email | RSS |


Podcast Archive

Podcast Summary

  • Michigan Wolverines football with Phil Callihan and Clint Derringer.0:00
    • Michigan football team prepares to play with anger and fire.
  • Michigan football team’s recent drama and upcoming game.1:26
    • Clint Derringer expects Michigan to win by multiple scores if they execute cleanly and stay healthy, citing their advantage in every phase of the game.
    • Phil Callihan finds it hard to believe it was only a week ago that he was in Happy Valley for Michigan’s victory, given the drama surrounding Jim Harbaugh’s status.
    • Phil Callihan analyzes the recent events surrounding Michigan football, including Jim Harbaugh’s suspension and Chris Partridge’s departure, and wonders how much drama the team can handle.
    • Callihan reflects on the team’s ability to “glance off” blows in the past, but notes that the current situation may be too much for them to handle.
  • Michigan football scandal and coaching staff changes.7:21
    • Michigan football faces logistical challenges with Harbaugh’s suspension and Partridge’s lack of cooperation in investigation.
    • Clint Derringer: Scandal disrupts Michigan football, puts players’ success at risk
    • Analysts discuss Coach Harbaugh’s use of biblical references and its potential connection to the team’s current suspension.
  • College football team’s controversies and media coverage.13:54
    • Callihan expresses frustration with media attention on Michigan football’s NCAA violations, believing it’s a “stupid, media-driven narrative.”
    • Phil Callihan discusses Maryland’s season, highlighting their ups and downs.
    • Callihan expresses frustration with media attention on Michigan’s infraction, speculates on potential damages and future investigations.
  • Michigan football’s game against Maryland amidst coaching staff changes and media scrutiny.20:32
    • Clint Derringer: Michigan’s approach to dealing with scandals has been good, focusing on wins to prove doubters wrong.
    • Derringer: Players are motivated to make it sweeter, despite added adversity, and a win against Ohio State could change the narrative.
    • Clint Derringer predicts Maryland’s offense will struggle due to lack of talent at wide receiver, while quarterback Thalia Tagovailoa is capable of big plays but prone to mistakes.
    • Michigan football coach Jim Harbaugh discusses team’s resilience in face of media scrutiny.

Nothing But ‘Net – Week #03 – 11/13/2023 – Non-Conference Non-Cupcakes

The University of Michigan men’s basketball team played two games this past week, and they won both of them.  On Tuesday (11/07/2023), they beat UNC-Asheville 99-74, then on Friday (11/10/2023), they beat Youngstown State 92-62.  Both games were in Crisler Arena.  The two wins raise Michigan’s record to 2-0.

What Happened?

Normally, most high-major teams schedule real “cupcakes” for their first few home games, to kind of “ease into” the season.  Not Michigan, not this season.  Both UNCA and YSU are good, solid opponents with impressive records last season, and strong returning lineups.  Michigan made them both look like traditional “cupcakes”, but they’re both a notch up from that.  Michigan just played very well in both games, and got the blowout wins they deserved.  It’s an important psychological advantage to win your exhibition games (ahem: Tennessee 89, MSU 88) and your first home game (ahem, again: James Madison 79, MSU 76), and Michigan took care of business.  Of course, if you shoot 1-for-20 from 3-point range, you could lose to a mid-major team in your home opener.  Just sayin’…

The UNCA game started with a UM turnover and 2 made free throws for UNCA.  That was the only time UM trailed the whole game.  Michigan made a 3-pointer to go up 3-2, and they never looked back.  They got the lead up to 9 points (15-6) with 14:54 to go in the 1st half, then 15 points (31-16) at the 9:05 mark.  They got the 1st half lead as high as 21 points (48-27) with 2:18 left in the half, but let UNCA score the last 5 points of the half, for a 16-point lead (48-32) at halftime.  Michigan put the game out of reach in the first 5 minutes of the 2nd half with a 19-8 run to make it a 27-point lead (67-40) with 15:02 to go.  The rest of the game, Michigan kept the lead between 20 and 29 points, even with the Scout Team in the game for the last 3 minutes.  It was a dominating performance against a good opponent.

The YSU game was all Michigan for the whole game.  UM led 4-0, YSU got within 2 points (4-2), then Michigan pulled away for good.  They led by 8 points (18-10) with 14:13 to go in the 1st half, then 11 points (26-15) with 9:39 left.  They led by 10 points (33-23) with 3:57 to go in the half, then they went on a 13-0 run to end the half up 46-23.  Just a little basketball pro-tip: it’s not good to be doubled up at halftime.  Michigan came out in the 2nd half and kept doubling (or more) YSU’s score: 50-25, 59-28, 65-30, 74-36, 76-38, and 81-40.  Once the lead got over 40 points, Michigan emptied the bench, and YSU made the score look a little more respectable, losing by “only” 30 points.  It was another dominating performance against another good opponent.

Stats

The game stats for the UNCA game were predictably good.  Michigan shot well overall (38-for-67 = 56.7%), they shot 3-pointers well (12-for-26 = 46.2%), and they shot free throws decently (11-for-15 = 73.3%).  They won the rebounding battle (39-30) and the turnover battle (9-13).  They won this game with good shooting and rebounding.

The game stats for the YSU game were good, but not as good as the UNCA stats.  Michigan shot well overall (35-for-66 = 53.0%), they shot 3-pointers fairly well (9-for-26 = 34.6%), and they shot free throws very well (13-for-16 = 81.3%).  They won the rebounding battle (41-31) and the turnover battle (11-13).  They won this game with continued good shooting and rebounding.

Who Started?

The starters for both games were Nimari Burnett, Dug McDaniel, Olivier Nkamhoua, Tarris Reed, Jr., and Terrance Williams II.

Who Looked Good?

Nkamhoua was the leading scorer in the UNCA game, with 25 points, and the second leading scorer in the YSU game, with 17 points.  He was also Michigan’s leading rebounder in both games, with 7 and 10 rebounds, which gave him a nice double-double in the YSU game.  He shot very well: 11-for-16 (1-for-4 from deep) vs. UNCA, and 7-for-7 (1-for-1 from deep) vs. YSU.  He also played very good defense.  He was the best player on the floor for both games.

McDaniel was the second leading scorer in the UNCA game, with 22 points, and the third leading scorer in the YSU game, with 16 points.  He had 8 assists vs. UNCA and 4 assists vs. YSU.  He looked very poised and confident out there.

Will Tschetter was the star of the YSU game, with 20 points off the bench.  He was the leading scorer, and he did it with style: 8-for-8 shooting, including 4-for-4 from deep.  He had a very interesting stat line: 20 points, 0 rebounds, 0 assists.  All he did was shoot, and shoot well.  20 points is a new career high for him, breaking his old career high of 8 points that he set in the UNCA game.  He also shot well in that game: 3-for-5 overall, 2-for-2 from deep.  Just for reference, he only scored 63 points in 27 games last season.

Williams had two very good games, which is very encouraging.  He scored 15 points vs. UNCA and 13 points vs. YSU.  He shot well in both games: 5-for-8 overall (3-for-5 from deep) vs. UNCA, and 4-for-8 (2-for-4 from deep) vs. YSU.  He even chipped in 6 and 8 rebounds.

Burnett had one good game (13 points vs. UNCA) and one lousy game (0 points vs. YSU).  As the starting shooting guard, Michigan needs consistent scoring from him.

Reed was very consistent, with 9 points in each game.  He still hasn’t played much (20 minutes vs. UNCA, 19 minutes vs. YSU); I don’t know if he’s recovering from illness or injury.

Who Looked Not-So-Good?

Tray Jackson played in both games, and scored 3 and 6 points.  He showed flashes of solid play, then he just drifted around the rest of the time.

Youssef Khayat played in both games, scoring 2 and 4 points.  He also got another technical foul, in the YSU game.  He’s a little bit of a “loose cannon” out there.

George Washington III finally scored his first career points in the YSU game (5 points, on 2-for-4 shooting, 1-for-2 from deep) after going scoreless in his debut against UNCA.  Once again, he’s a freshman, he’ll get better.

Who Else Played?

Ian Burns played for 2 minutes vs. UNCA and 7 minutes vs. YSU.  He scored his first career points in the YSU game, hitting both of his free throw attempts.

Harrison Hochberg played for 2 minutes vs. UNCA and 3 minutes vs. YSU.  He didn’t shoot in the UNCA game, and missed his only free throw attempt in the YSU game.

Jackson Selvala played for 2 minutes vs. UNCA and 7 minutes vs. YSU.  He missed his only shot attempt vs. UNCA, and didn’t shoot vs. YSU.

Cooper Smith played for 3 minutes in each game, and scored 2 points vs. UNCA.  He was 1-for-1 vs. UNCA, and 0-for-1 vs. YSU.

Who Didn’t Play?

Everyone who wasn’t injured played at least 2 minutes in each game.  The injured players are: Jace Howard and Jaelin Llewellyn.

What Does It Mean?

Could Michigan be better than the “experts” predicted?  It’s a little early to say, but based on how they played against two quality opponents, maybe?  We’ll know more after their next game.  See below.

What’s Next?

This week, Michigan plays two games.  On Monday (11/13/2023, 6:30 p.m., FS1) they play St. John’s in Madison Square Garden in New York City, then on Friday (11/17/2023, 7:00 p.m., BTN+) they play Long Beach State in Crisler Arena.  The St. John’s game is part of the Gavitt Tip-Off Games, which is the annual Big East/Big Ten challenge.  This is the last season for the Gavitt Games.

St. John’s was 18-15 last season, 7-13 in the Big East.  They beat (#6) UConn and (#20) Providence, lost in the 2nd round of the Big East tournament, and didn’t play in a post-season tournament.  They don’t have any noteworthy players, and they don’t have much height: just one 6’11” player.  They do have a noteworthy coach: Rick Pitino.  That alone makes them dangerous.  This will be an important test for Michigan.  They’ve looked good at home against mid-major teams, but now they’ll be playing on the road against a team from a big conference.  Sure, it’s technically a “neutral site” game, but it’s a lot like a home game for St. John’s.

Long Beach State was 17-16 last season, 11-9 in the Big West.  They didn’t beat anyone notable, lost in the 1st round of the Big West tournament, and didn’t play in a post-season tournament.  They don’t have any noteworthy players, but they do have a little height: two 6’10” players, and a 6’11” player.  This is a game that Michigan should win, as long as they don’t do anything crazy.

Check back next week to find out what happened and why.

Go Blue!