Phil Callihan and Clint Derringer discuss Michigan’s 38-21 loss to Indiana. Topics include what went wrong, QB Joe Milton’s performance, troubles on defense, and much more.
Final Score: 21-38, Indiana by 17 over Michigan SP+ Projection: Michigan by 2.1 (-19.1) CD Projection: Michigan by 1 (-18)
FIVE FACTORS
WEEK 3 RECAP @ Indiana
For the second week in a row, Michigan was outplayed and lost. In some sense you have to give the Hoosiers the respect they deserve. That doesn’t help soothe the deep disappointment for this team. Jim Harbaugh must go back to the drawing board and get all his guys onto the same page. If he cannot keep the team together through this challenging season, it will be hard for me to believe he can restore the program.
The Michigan offensive line was behind the eight ball right away without both starting tackles. The running game was only able to produce an 8% success rate, and 1.6 yards per play. On the first watch, I didn’t see very much read-option, if at all. I don’t know why there is such hesitation to use Joe Milton in the run game, but it’s clearly been taken out of the game plan. I will give Gattis and Joe Milton a lot of credit for bouncing back in the second half. The offense was dangerous enough in the 2nd half to threaten the whole field, but still couldn’t click in the most critical spots.
The Hoosiers copied the Michigan State offensive game plan of chuck and hope versus the Michigan corners. It was almost as successful this week. There was a clear commitment to back off into more zone coverages to take some heat off Vincent Gray and Gemon Green. Indiana was able to find large holes and Michael Penix had a career day. There was pressure on Penix, and Michigan caused some errant throws. This was despite Aiden Hutchinson leaving with an apparent foot or ankle injury in the first quarter. The defense managed to slow Indiana down in the 2nd half, but could not get off the field on key plays. Indiana ran 87 snaps on offense, compared to just 52 for Michigan.
Phil Callihan and Clint Derringer use the SP+ factors to preview Michigan’s next game versus Indiana and the need for Wolverines to come back strong after last week’s disappointing loss.
Michigan State upset the Wolverines 27-24, as Michigan was outplayed at home in stunning fashion by their rivals.
NEXT UP: @ Indiana: 25th, 11.5
PREGAME SP+: Michigan by 2.1, Michigan Win Probability 55% The Hoosiers are 2-0, and have performed pretty much as expected according to SP+. The win over Penn State was a statistical anomaly. Indiana would have lost if Penn State had taken a knee instead of handing off. They were also kick-started by two short fields in the first half against Rutgers.
Michigan Offense (29th) vs. Indiana Defense (26th) The Michigan rushing attack will be my main offensive key on Saturday. Indiana ranks 10th in Big Ten rushing yards allowed per game. Michigan was able to produce a 48% success rate on called run plays versus Michigan State (ranked 7th in B1G rush yds/game). Despite being somewhat successful, the offensive line had trouble adapting to how MSU attacked their blocking scheme. This produced far more negative yardage plays than Josh Gattis would like. The Wolverines may also be dealing with some injuries up front, including their best lineman Jaylen Mayfield.
Michigan Defense (13th) vs. Indiana Offense (33rd) Regardless of which two Michigan cornerbacks get the start in Bloomington, I expect Don Brown to give them additional help from the safeties. The success of MSU’s chuck-it-deep approach last week will definitely be imitated by the rest of the Big Ten teams versus Michigan. The key questions I’ll be looking to answer: How well can Dax Hill and Brad Hawkins perform in coverage? Can the corners function in coverage without overtly grabbing the Indiana wide receivers? Can the defensive line and blitzing linebackers get to QB Michael Penix before he can find the holes in more frequent zone coverage by the Wolverines?
PREDICTION: Indiana has been pretty consistent through two weeks, and they are now 2-0 and ranked 13th nationally. Michigan has already visited both ends of the performance and expectations spectrum. No metric system can answer whether or not the 2020 Michigan team can bounce back from a shocking loss. I expect a better-prepared and more enthusiastic showing this week, but the stat sheet might not reflect that. This game could remind Michigan fans of last year’s Iowa game, a 10-3 home victory. My advice is to focus on what really matters…win the game! Michigan 28 Indiana 27 (PRESEASON Michigan 35 Indiana 20)
Phil Callihan and Clint Derringer discuss Michigan’s unexpected 27-24 loss to Michigan State. Topics include how the SP+ predictions compared to the actual result, Michigan State QB Rocky Lombardi, Michigan’s play calling, the referees, and much more.