I hate to rain on the parade but give me a year where the BCS got it absolutely wrong. Yes, there have been teams that went undefeated but nearly every year - if not EVERY year - the BCS ended with the best team receiving the national title crown. Even when Florida was voted in over us they pummeled OSU.
If they make it anything more than a 4 team playoff they're reaching. If you can't make the top 4 you've got no reason to cry.
2000 - 1 loss FSU gets nod over 1 loss Miami team that beat FSU. Miami's 1 loss came to Washington...another 1 loss team. 2 teams were screwed over that season.
2001 - Nebraska, despite losing 62-36 in their regular season finale to Colorado and their berth in the Big 12 title game as well, was chosen over a 1 loss Oregon and the 2 loss Big 12 champs that flat out destroyed them. Nebraska would be embarrassed by Miami in the national title game and Oregon routed Colorado in the Fiesta. Oregon was screwed over that season.
2003 - Oklahoma, LSU, and USC all finished the season with 1 loss. BCS selects LSU and non conference champion Oklahoma to play for title.
2004 - Auburn left out in favor of Oklahoma mostly based on Auburn's loss to USC the year before.
2006 - Michigan, Wisconsin, Louisville, and Florida all with 1 loss. Boise State would finish as the only undefeated team that year. Florida, Ohio State, Wisconsin, and Louisville all finished as 1 loss teams.
2008 - 1 loss Bama, 1 loss Florida, 1 loss Oklahoma, 1 loss Texas, 1 loss Texas Tech, undefeated Utah, and undefeated Boise State. Oklahoma's 1 loss was to Texas, Texas' was to Texas Tech, Tech's was to Oklahoma. Florida's was to Ole Miss and Bama's was to Florida in the SEC title game. Utah would finish the season as the only undefeated team crushing Bama in the Sugar Bowl. Florida and Texas both finished the season with 1 loss.
2009 - 5 teams undefeated going into bowl season. Texas, Bama, TCU, Boise, and Cincy. Boise and Bama would both finish with 14-0 records
2010 - Undefeated TCU would be on the outside looking in after defeating Wisconsin (that many believed to be the team playing the best in the country going into the bowls) in the Rose Bowl.
2011 - Okie State given no chance.
If there is any doubt that the BCS is leaving one of the 2 best teams in the country out of the title game than the system is wrong.
<message edited by Maize927 on Monday, April 09, 2012 1:06 PM>